[Underspecified semantics] Type check defaults at declaration.
Fixes #46669. See the test for code that compiles on stable but will no longer compile. This falls under a "Underspecified language semantics" fix. **Needs crater**.
On type and trait declarations, we currently allow anything that name checks as a type parameter default. That allows the user to write a default that can never be applied, or even a default that may conditionally be applied depending on the type of another parameter. Mostly this just defers the error to use sites, but also allows clever hacks such as `Foo<T, U = <T as Iterator>::Item>` where `U` will be able to apply it's default only when `T: Iterator`. Maybe that means this bug is a feature, but it's a fiddly behaviour that seems undesirable.
This PR validates defaults at declaration sites by ensuring all predicates on the parameter are valid for the default. With the exception of `Self: Sized` which we don't want to check to allow things like `trait Add<RHS = Self>`.
This commit is targeted at addressing #48251 by specifically fixing a case where
a longjmp over Rust frames on MSVC runs cleanups, accidentally running the
"abort the program" cleanup as well. Added in #46833 `extern` ABI functions in
Rust will abort the process if Rust panics, and currently this is modeled as a
normal cleanup like all other destructors.
Unfortunately it turns out that `longjmp` on MSVC is implemented with SEH, the
same mechanism used to implement panics in Rust. This means that `longjmp` over
Rust frames will run Rust cleanups (even though we don't necessarily want it
to). Notably this means that if you `longjmp` over a Rust stack frame then that
probably means you'll abort the program because one of the cleanups will abort
the process.
After some discussion on IRC it turns out that `longjmp` doesn't run cleanups
for *caught* exceptions, it only runs cleanups for cleanup pads. Using this
information this commit tweaks the codegen for an `extern` function to
a catch-all clause for exceptions instead of a cleanup block. This catch-all is
equivalent to the C++ code:
try {
foo();
} catch (...) {
bar();
}
and in fact our codegen here is designed to match exactly what clang emits for
that C++ code!
With this tweak a longjmp over Rust code will no longer abort the process. A
longjmp will continue to "accidentally" run Rust cleanups (destructors) on MSVC.
Other non-MSVC platforms will not rust destructors with a longjmp, so we'll
probably still recommend "don't have destructors on the stack", but in any case
this is a more surgical fix than #48567 and should help us stick to standard
personality functions a bit longer.
Given a trait predicate, if all params appearing in the LHS have
defaults then it should be a backwards compatible predicate. We verify
that by checking the WF of predicate with all defaults substituted
simultaneously.
